Stephanie Davies-Arai has posted an especially clear assessment of why feminism cannot accommodate transgenderism.
Maria Miller’s Report Puts Feminists In An Impossible Position
“Maria Miller has stated that she is ‘taken aback’ by the ”hostility’ towards the government’s recent transgender report from ‘purported feminists.’ She says: “I think that all of us who are feminists know that equality for other groups of people, and a fairer deal for other groups of people, is good for us as well.”
Yes of course, as a society nobody wants to see any group suffering discrimination so why would anyone give more than a passing nod of approval to this new report, even those horrible feminists?
This time it’s not so simple; ‘transgender’ is not one of those ‘other groups’ defined by distinct boundaries, as all other minority groups are. By definition, ‘transgender’ stakes claim to membership of already existing groups; the mantra ‘transwomen are women’ accordingly puts them into two protected categories; both ‘transgender’ and ‘women’.”
The post may be read in its entirety on her blog.